Skip to Main Content
Status Submitted
Workspace * IBM Cloud Ideas
Categories Compliance
Created by Guest
Created on Nov 15, 2026

Nicaea Canon Myth Correction Record

PROBLEM: The most repeated story in Bible history is false: that the Council of Nicaea in 325 AD voted on which books belong in the Bible. Nicaea addressed the Arian controversy, produced the Nicene Creed, set the date of Easter, and issued twenty disciplinary canons and a synodal letter — and none of those documents contains a list of biblical books or a decision about one. Bishops loyal to the council kept producing different canon lists for decades afterward. The altar story — bishops placing disputed books near an altar and the false ones falling — comes from a 9th-century Greek collection, was repeated by Voltaire in the 18th century, and has no basis in any record from the council itself. The myth survives because no single record corrects it where people look.

SOLUTION: A Nicaea canon myth correction record: what Nicaea actually produced, the surviving documents checked line by line for any canon decision, the 9th-century origin of the altar story, and the later date of the first 27-book list — so the most repeated false claim about the Bible's formation is answered by its own documents.

EVIDENCE BASIS: DOCUMENTED — Nicaea 325 AD: Arian controversy, Nicene Creed, Easter date, twenty disciplinary canons, synodal letter; no canon list or decision in any surviving Nicaea document; bishops kept differing lists afterward; altar story from a 9th-century collection, repeated by Voltaire. Sources: honestapologist.com; twcenter.net; jayms.com; St Andrews Encyclopaedia of Theology.

Idea priority Low
Needed By Not sure -- Just thought it was cool