TITLE: Inmate Sterilization Approval-Committee Record
PROBLEM: The California State Auditor found that between fiscal years 2005–06 and 2012–13, 144 female inmates were sterilized by tubal ligation — and the two approval committees required by the process (a prison committee and a headquarters committee) approved only 1 of the 144 procedures. The Receiver's Office, which controlled prison medical care from 2006, said it did not even learn sterilizations were happening until January 2010. The safeguards were not just bypassed; they were invisible — no committee record showed what was approved, what was not, and what happened anyway. California banned the practice for birth control in 2014 and created a $35,000 reparations program in 2021, but the approval record that would have stopped it in 2006 still does not exist as a standing system.
SOLUTION: An inmate sterilization approval-committee record: every proposed sterilization logged with both committees' decisions, the medical-necessity finding, and the outcome — with any procedure performed without both approvals flagged immediately — so a safeguard failure is visible the day it happens, not eight years later in an audit.
EVIDENCE BASIS: DOCUMENTED — California State Auditor Report 2013-120, June 2014: 144 tubal ligations FY 2005–06 through 2012–13; both committees approved only 1 of 144; Receiver's Office unaware until Jan 2010; 2014 California law banning sterilization for birth control in prisons and jails; 2021 reparations program ($35,000 per person). Sources: California State Auditor; Center for Investigative Reporting (2013); Bolts Magazine.
| Idea priority | Low |
| Needed By | Not sure -- Just thought it was cool |
By clicking the "Post Comment" or "Submit Idea" button, you are agreeing to the IBM Ideas Portal Terms of Use.
Do not place IBM confidential, company confidential, or personal information into any field.