Skip to Main Content
Status Submitted
Workspace * IBM Cloud Ideas
Categories Compliance
Created by Guest
Created on Nov 22, 2026

GitHub Copilot Contract Record: DMCA Claim Dismissed on Appeal, Contract Claims Remain

PROBLEM: Programmers can sue over code used to train a coding assistant, with the copyright-management claim decided on appeal while contract claims remain, yet there is no standard record separating the decided claim from the pending ones — so the case is reported as over when it is not.

SOLUTION: A code-training litigation record: the filing, the district court, the appellate ruling and mandate date, and the contract claims that remain pending — one record per case, with the decided and the pending stated side by side.

EVIDENCE BASIS: DOCUMENTED — Doe v. GitHub (GitHub Copilot), filed Nov 2022, N.D. Cal. (Judge Tigar). Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal of the DMCA §1202(b) claim Sept 16, 2026 (No. 24-7700); mandate issued Oct 8, 2026; two breach-of-contract claims remain pending in district court. Related: Andersen v. Stability AI (N.D. Cal. 3:23-cv-00201) — DMCA claims dismissed with prejudice Aug 12, 2024; discovery ongoing as of Nov 16, 2026. Sources: research note ai-company-cases-20261120.md (D21). The combined AI litigation and regulatory records system is inventor CONCEPT ONLY.

Idea priority Low
Needed By Not sure -- Just thought it was cool