Skip to Main Content
Status Submitted
Workspace * IBM Cloud Ideas
Categories Compliance
Created by Guest
Created on Nov 22, 2026

Smith Neutral-Law Record: General Applicability and Exemptions

PROBLEM: A neutral law can burden a religious practice, yet there is no standard record tying the burden to the rule that decides whether an exemption is owed — so the general-applicability rule is quoted without the case that set it or the response it provoked.

SOLUTION: A neutral-law record: the case, the law, the burden, the rule, and the statute it provoked — one record per case, so the rule and its response travel together.

EVIDENCE BASIS: DOCUMENTED — *Employment Division v. Smith*, 494 U.S. 872 (1990): Oregon's neutral, generally applicable criminal ban on peyote could be applied to deny unemployment benefits to Native American Church members; a neutral law of general applicability needs no religious exemption under the Free Exercise Clause. Congress enacted RFRA in 1993 "in direct response" to *Smith*. Sources: research note faith-spiritual-defense-20261121.md (D4, D5). The combined faith key system is inventor CONCEPT ONLY.

Idea priority Low
Needed By Not sure -- Just thought it was cool