PROBLEM: Some states criminalize HIV exposure even when transmission is impossible, punishing people for a risk that does not exist and discouraging the testing that prevention depends on. Without a record of how these laws actually work — who is prosecuted, for what, and whether transmission was possible — reform has no evidence base.
SOLUTION: A criminalization reform record that logs exposure-law prosecutions with their facts: whether transmission was possible, whether the partner tested negative, what the sentence was, and how many cases the state prosecuted — so the law is judged on its record, not its intent.
EVIDENCE BASIS: DOCUMENTED — The Buckeye Flame / Marshall Project, Mar 13, 2024: Caymir Weaver, born with HIV in New Jersey in 2001, undetectable on treatment, was charged with felonious assault for not notifying a partner; there was "little to no risk" of transmitting the virus and the partner tested negative; Judge R. Scott Krichbaum (Mahoning County Common Pleas, first elected 1990) sentenced one year in prison plus 30 extra days in county jail; Ohio has six laws criminalizing acts for people living with HIV or increasing penalties; Equality Ohio / Ohio Health Modernization Movement tallied 214 cases prosecuted over a six-year period across Ohio's 88 counties; about a third were felonious assault, more than half "harassment" with a bodily substance; Ohio law does not distinguish fluids that transmit HIV from those that do not; CDC has warned criminalization laws are ineffective and can discourage testing; Ohio's laws date to 1989, amended 2000 to criminalize exposure, not transmission (F5).
| Idea priority | Low |
| Needed By | Not sure -- Just thought it was cool |
By clicking the "Post Comment" or "Submit Idea" button, you are agreeing to the IBM Ideas Portal Terms of Use.
Do not place IBM confidential, company confidential, or personal information into any field.