PROBLEM
The most sensational claim in the book — that the NSA recruited Perkins in the late 1960s and directed his work through a handler he names "Claudine" — is also the least supported: Perkins offers no document, order, or named handler, and the State Department's rebuttal notes that "nowhere in his book does he claim that anyone at the NSA gave him any written or verbal directions." The claim circulates as fact anyway, because no record separates it from the rest of the account.
SOLUTION
An NSA-recruitment claim record that logs the claim exactly as Perkins states it, logs the absence of corroboration, and logs the rebuttal — the NSA's missions are cryptology and signals intelligence, not placing economists at private firms — so the claim stays graded REPORTED and is never filed as a documented fact.
EVIDENCE BASIS
REPORTED — Perkins says he was recruited by the NSA in the late 1960s, trained by "Claudine," and that the CIA/NSA used private firms so the government was not directly implicated (F05). DOCUMENTED — State Department rebuttal (Feb 2006): the claim "appears to be a total fabrication"; his 1968 NSA job interview "seems credible" but there is "no reason to believe" the NSA or any other agency except the Peace Corps played a role (F18). "Claudine" appears only in Perkins' account; no independent record was found — held out as a verified person.
| Idea priority | Low |
| Needed By | Not sure -- Just thought it was cool |
By clicking the "Post Comment" or "Submit Idea" button, you are agreeing to the IBM Ideas Portal Terms of Use.
Do not place IBM confidential, company confidential, or personal information into any field.